Domain Registration

Turkish state blocks choosing of a new Armenian Patriarch

  • February 22, 2018

For a sixth time given a initial of a Turkish Republic in 1923, a supervision of constitutionally “secular” Turkey has plainly intervened in a preference of a new Armenian Patriarch to lead a nation’s largest Christian community.

Patriarch Mesrob II Mutafyan was diagnosed with insanity and Alzheimer’s illness and strictly late in Oct 2016 (Turkiye Ermenileri Patrikligi)
Patriarch Mesrob II Mutafyan was strictly late in Oct 2016 (Turkiye Ermenileri Patrikligi)

Now estimated during reduction than 40,000, Turkey’s Armenian village – located essentially in Istanbul – are a vestige of some 2 million Armenians who had lived in executive Anatolia and a eastern regions of what is now modern-day Turkey for dual millennia. An estimated 1.5 million died during massacres and forced deportations into a Syrian Desert, begun in Apr 1915 underneath a Ottoman Empire. Although Turkey acknowledges there were “casualties on both sides” during this time in World War I, it denies a events constituted a “genocide”.

Armenia was a initial nation in a universe to adopt Christianity as a state sacrament (in 301 AD). Today Istanbul’s ancestral Armenian Patriarchate oversees 42 churches and some-more than 50 village foundations in Turkey, ancillary their minority schools, hospitals, cemeteries and several free projects to accommodate a religious, educational and charitable needs of a community. But in early February, a Clerical Council of a Armenian Apostolic Patriarchate was systematic by a Turkish state to desert a efforts over a past 18 months to reinstate a obligatory Patriarch, who fell severely ill 10 years ago and is now in a coma.

Two years into his illness, Patriarch Mesrob II Mutafyan was diagnosed with insanity and Alzheimer’s disease. Since he could no longer lift out his duties, a Armenian village debated dual options: possibly electing a new Patriarch, or a proxy Co-Patriarch to do Mutafyan’s responsibilities until his death.

Archbishop Aram Ateşyan was inaugurated as Patriarchal Vicar General in 2010 (Agos)
Archbishop Aram Ateşyan was comparison to take on a purpose of Patriarchal Vicar General in 2010 (Agos)

But in 2010, a Turkish supervision argued that conjunction choosing would follow Armenian Church traditions, underneath that a Patriarch had possibly died or quiescent before his inheritor was elected. Instead, a state invented a new care purpose within a internal church hierarchy: a Patriarchal Vicar General to hoop a day-to-day affairs of a patriarchate. The Clerical Council afterwards comparison Archbishop Aram Ateşyan to fill this new post determined by a government.

Ateşyan remained in this state-appointed purpose as a de-facto personality of Turkey’s Armenian village for a following years. But in Oct 2016, a Clerical Council strictly late Patriarch Mesrob, observant that his incorrigible condition had rendered him incompetent to perform his duties for a past 7 years. At that point, a Armenian community’s expectations focused on rising a choosing routine for a new Patriarch.

But Ateşyan stalled for months, disappearing to correlate plainly with supervision officials to start choosing proceedings. Finally in Feb 2017 Bishop Safak Maşalyan quiescent in criticism as conduct of a Clerical Council. “The choosing atmosphere – always on a agenda, though never resolved – provides a belligerent for church groups and conflicts,” Maşalyan explained to religious-freedom watchdog Forum 18 final week.

Widespread village support shortly stirred Maşalyan to repel his resignation. The Clerical Council afterwards announced a congenital chair vacant, job for a choosing of a locum tenens (temporary leader) to start and manage a choosing process.

In further to Ateşyan and Maşalyan, dual other Armenian clergymen portion as devout leaders of Armenian communities abroad were authorised as Turkish-born adults and peaceful to manage a choosing process: Archbishop Sebuh Çulciyan in Armenia and Archbishop Karekin Bekçiyan in Germany.

Episkopos Sahak Maşalyan (Agos)
Bishop Episkopos Sahak Maşalyan quiescent as conduct of a Clerical Council in Feb 2017 (Agos)

In an choosing during 3pm on 15 March, 2017, Bekçiyan was elected, with a two-thirds infancy over a other candidates, to offer as a locum tenens. Minutes later, Ateşyan produced a formerly undisclosed minute from a Istanbul Governorate that had been faxed to a patriarchate progressing that day, dogmatic it was “legally impossible” for a church to ensue with congenital elections. Stating that a Patriarchal Vicar General was still in assign of patriarchate affairs, a minute expelled to a press warned that starting choosing activities could “cause splits in a Armenian community”.

Pointedly, Istanbul’s weekly Armenian Agos journal reported that a minute from a Governor’s bureau had been faxed to a patriarchate during 1.47pm, some-more than an hour before a choosing was held. By implication, apparently usually Ateşyan knew before a opinion took place that a supervision was ominous a election.

Bekçiyan was invited to come from Germany in early Apr to take adult his proxy authorized position in a Istanbul patriarchate. But Ateşyan refused to renounce from his possess state-appointed post. As a result, in late Jun a Clerical Council voted 22 to dual to mislay Ateşyan from his Vicar-General role.

Seven-month stalemate

But for a 7 months since, a Turkish state has declined any communication with Bekçiyan, withdrawal unanswered all his letters and requested appointments as a Armenian Church’s selected devout leader. The usually open supervision hit with a village was channelled by distinguished lay businessman Bedros Şirinoğlu, who heads one of a largest Armenian village foundations and met final open with Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan.

The Armenian Patriarchate in Istanbul (World Watch Monitor)
The Armenian Patriarchate in Istanbul (World Watch Monitor)

Frustrated by a ongoing central silence, a patriarchate’s Election Steering Committee finally filed a censure opposite a Interior Ministry progressing this month for a disaster to respond to a Church’s focus to start a choosing process.

On 6 February, a Istanbul Governorate pennyless a overpower in a created response to a Patriarchate, dogmatic that “conditions for a choosing of a new Patriarch have not materialised” – i.e. Patriarch Mesrob is still alive, health reasons do not leave his position vacant, and Ateşyan is still a Patriarchal Vicar General, a minute stated.

The subsequent day, laymen streamer a Armenian community’s foundations were summoned along with a patriarchate’s counsel to accommodate with Interior Minister Süleyman Soylu during Istanbul’s Çırağan Palace. None of a church’s devout care were invited, though Soylu was flanked by Istanbul Governor Vasip Şahin as good as a Istanbul Chief of Police, a Istanbul gendarmerie commander-general and several other comparison officials.

Attorney Sebouh Aslangil told a Interior Minister that a Armenian Clerical Council had taken all a actions over past months in suitability with church rules, including stealing Ateşyan from his post as Patriarchal Vicar General.

But Soylu insisted that Turkey was “acting underneath a law”, observant it was a state’s avocation to recognize a purpose of a congenital vicar.

“The supervision has plainly intervened in a traditions of a church and told them that they can't elect their possess Patriarch.”


Quoted by CNNTURK on 8 February, Soylu specified that a statute by a Turkish Council of Ministers on 29 June, 2010, had intended that “until Mutafyan died, Aram Ateşyan would sojourn as a Patriarchal Vicar-General”.

After several member of a village explained because it was critical for a congenital elections to take place immediately, Soylu pronounced he would communicate their concerns to President Erdoğan and Prime Minister Binali Yildirim. “We contingency accommodate again in about a month,” he resolved after a three-hour meeting.

Later that day, an Agos editorial concluded: “The [ruling] AK [Justice and Development] Party supervision has plainly intervened in a traditions of a church and told them that they can't elect their possess Patriarch.”

On a heels of Soylu’s meeting, a Clerical Council bent to a supervision division a subsequent day, rigourously reinstating Archbishop Aram Ateşyan on 9 Feb as a “acting” Patriarch. Four days later, Bekçiyan returned to Germany, describing a Turkish government’s division as a “long and designed campaign” to harm Turkey’s 85th congenital elections.

Established authorised vacuum

“It’s an ‘established practice’ that a [Turkish] state interferes in how some eremite communities elect their leaders, quite a Armenian, Greek Orthodox and Jewish communities,” Forum 18 said final week in a minute examination of a new congenital elections saga.

Essentially, it said, a deficiency of a authorised horizon for Turkey’s Armenians and other non-Muslim minorities continues to violate a country’s general religious-freedom obligations, as spelled out in a Lausanne Treaty and a possess constitution.

“The genuine problem lies in a deficiency of any law on a institutions of eremite minorities, and a Turkish government’s refusal to recognize those institutions as authorised personalities,” Turkish human-rights counsel Orhan Kemal Cengiz told Al-Monitor final year.

Without a authorised horizon to strengthen their full eremite rights, Turkey’s Armenian adults sojourn contingent on a domestic “good will” of a supervision in energy to even select their possess devout leaders.

Related Articles:

Article source:

Related News